I didn’t want to link to the actual article because I’m a little embarrassed for her. She meant to praise us, but just did a terrible job of it. I don’t want to sick the internet on her for bad writing.
I can maybe see where she though she was being sarcastic…but it didn’t work.
Haven’t been able to come to a show (poor Midwestern college student blah blah) but from I read on here and see on your videos, you two ladies manage to blow right past smart and funny to brilliant and hilarious.
Hey, I read the (otherwise rave) review over at Glennis’s blog, and I have to ask… are you sure she wasn’t just trying to be facetious? But was ironically not smart or funny enough to pull it off?
I think that writer is regretting saying that at the end of her article. She probably wrote it thinking it would sound one way, but came across in another, completely horrible way. I do that sometimes, too.
I had something to say here.…. But it was already said (quite well I must add.).…. So, to say what I wanted to say.… while being lazy… i’ll just blatently plagiarize:
“Catie Says:
June 2nd, 2008 at 7:24 pm I can maybe see where she though she was being sarcastic…but it didn’t work.
Haven’t been able to come to a show (*removed quote that does not apply to me * — Kenny g.) but from what I read on here and see on your videos, you two ladies manage to blow right past smart and funny to brilliant and hilarious.”
Big props to Catie for writing a post spot-on enough for two.…
But, after reading the actual review on Glennis’s blog.… I do have to add.…. Megn Striklan!!! You couldn’t compose sarcastic, ironic prose if you.… um… I dunno… Had SARS, were in a cast.… and maybe it was made of iron..??? ( I ran out of ideas… too much beer.… and you can’t write straight when you are this offended with media irresponsibility.… )
Nuff said… except.… gotta say.… you both look SMOKINHAWT in the photo.… but that’s just my opinion.…
Hi y’all. I’m a critic so I obviously have a different slant on this. In my reading of the review, she’s trying to comment (fairly ineffectively) on the popular stereotype that women aren’t funny. And looking over the review, the positive to negative ratio of what the reviewer says is about 50 to 1. She praises just about everything about you all, down to your fashion sense. And then, in a probably ill-considered move, she tried to be funny or ironic with her last line and you all are hanging her with it. Haven’t you ever done a killer routine and then kind of muffed the last line? It seems like what happened here. This kind of reaction is the kind of thing that makes me pretty bitter as a critic. I’ve heaped praise on all sorts of aspects of a show and then been accosted because I said something less-than-positive about the set or the lighting. Would the only appropriate last line have been “go see these chicks because the sun shines out of their collective ass”?
Bio
Eliza Skinner is a comedian, writer, and performer living in Los Angeles. She is part of Diamond Lion and member of Baby Wants Candy improvised musical.
Huh… sounds like someone needs kicked square in the nuts.
Yeah, you broads are pretty awesome… when you’re manage to find your way out of the kitchen for a moment.
File her under: Part of the Problem.
PS. Your hair is awesome in that photo!
Who, may I ask, wrote that and where?
Except of course that I can’t read so maybe it doesn’t matter.
And then to say pretty close?
Sister, please!
Uh wtf? Was that lady high on glue and fresh from a trip seeing the Sex and the City movie? Yeesh!
I didn’t want to link to the actual article because I’m a little embarrassed for her. She meant to praise us, but just did a terrible job of it. I don’t want to sick the internet on her for bad writing.
Maybe she meant “in a bizarro world where women aren’t funny.” Or maybe this was her pitch for a science fiction movie preview.
I can maybe see where she though she was being sarcastic…but it didn’t work.
Haven’t been able to come to a show (poor Midwestern college student blah blah) but from I read on here and see on your videos, you two ladies manage to blow right past smart and funny to brilliant and hilarious.
Maybe the writer isn’t a REAL woman…
Hey, I read the (otherwise rave) review over at Glennis’s blog, and I have to ask… are you sure she wasn’t just trying to be facetious? But was ironically not smart or funny enough to pull it off?
I hope that’s what it was.
Wait, Charleston has a “City Paper”?
I think that writer is regretting saying that at the end of her article. She probably wrote it thinking it would sound one way, but came across in another, completely horrible way. I do that sometimes, too.
ladies, that is a really nice photo.
I had something to say here.…. But it was already said (quite well I must add.).…. So, to say what I wanted to say.… while being lazy… i’ll just blatently plagiarize:
“Catie Says:
June 2nd, 2008 at 7:24 pm
I can maybe see where she though she was being sarcastic…but it didn’t work.
Haven’t been able to come to a show (*removed quote that does not apply to me
* — Kenny g.) but from what I read on here and see on your videos, you two ladies manage to blow right past smart and funny to brilliant and hilarious.”
Big props to Catie for writing a post spot-on enough for two.…
But, after reading the actual review on Glennis’s blog.… I do have to add.…. Megn Striklan!!! You couldn’t compose sarcastic, ironic prose if you.… um… I dunno… Had SARS, were in a cast.… and maybe it was made of iron..??? ( I ran out of ideas… too much beer.… and you can’t write straight when you are this offended with media irresponsibility.… )
Nuff said… except.… gotta say.… you both look SMOKIN HAWT in the photo.… but that’s just my opinion.…
- Kenny G.
Hi y’all. I’m a critic so I obviously have a different slant on this. In my reading of the review, she’s trying to comment (fairly ineffectively) on the popular stereotype that women aren’t funny. And looking over the review, the positive to negative ratio of what the reviewer says is about 50 to 1. She praises just about everything about you all, down to your fashion sense. And then, in a probably ill-considered move, she tried to be funny or ironic with her last line and you all are hanging her with it. Haven’t you ever done a killer routine and then kind of muffed the last line? It seems like what happened here. This kind of reaction is the kind of thing that makes me pretty bitter as a critic. I’ve heaped praise on all sorts of aspects of a show and then been accosted because I said something less-than-positive about the set or the lighting. Would the only appropriate last line have been “go see these chicks because the sun shines out of their collective ass”?